Cultural Appropriation: Why You Should Be Wary of Some Drum Making Workshops

L-appropriation-culturelle-Pourquoi-vous-devez-être-vigilants-face-à-certains-ateliers-de-fabrication-de-Tambours Artisanat Autochtone




In a context where awareness of cultural appropriation is increasingly important, it is crucial to pay particular attention to companies that offer workshops for making cultural objects without a deep understanding of their meaning. A troubling example is that of a Quebec company that offers workshops for making drums inspired by Indigenous traditions.

What is cultural appropriation?

Cultural appropriation occurs when elements of one culture are taken and used by another culture without respect or proper understanding, often for commercial purposes. This can include sacred symbols, spiritual practices, or cultural objects whose meaning is reduced to a mere consumer product.

Risks associated with drum manufacturing workshops

Drums play a central role in many Indigenous cultures, serving as a means of communication, spiritual tools, and community symbols. When a company organizes drum-making workshops without a genuine connection to First Nations cultural traditions, several problems can arise:

1. Lack of respect for traditions : Drum-making workshops can trivialize deep spiritual practices by turning them into simple craft activities for non-initiates.

2. Commercial exploitation : By selling these drums as consumer products, the company can profit from a culture it does not understand or respect, while neglecting the profound meanings and values ​​associated with them. This impacts the Indigenous artisans who produce them and try to make a living from it.

3. Devaluation of Indigenous artisans : Indigenous artisans who authentically perpetuate these traditions may find themselves marginalized and their practices devalued by the mass production and industrialization of cultural objects.

How to identify and avoid cultural appropriation

To avoid supporting companies that participate in cultural appropriation, it is essential to:

- Seek compliance : Ensure that workshops are led by Indigenous people with a connection to the cultural traditions they teach, and that they respect Indigenous practices and knowledge.

- Check the sources : The materials used must come from respectful sources and comply with laws concerning cultural and spiritual practices.

- Consult Indigenous communities : Indigenous communities are the best sources of information to assess the legitimacy of proposed practices and workshops.

As consumers, it is our responsibility to be informed and ensure that our choices do not contribute to cultural appropriation. By avoiding drum-making workshops that do not respect Indigenous traditions, we support authentic practices and preserve the cultural richness of First Nations. Let us be vigilant and respectful of the cultures whose traditions we celebrate.

To learn more about the impacts of cultural appropriation in Quebec, also read this article on ESPACE AUTOCHTONE .

Foire aux questions

Q: What is meant by cultural appropriation in the context of drumming workshops?
A: Cultural appropriation occurs when sacred or traditional elements—in this case, the Indigenous drum—are taken without understanding or respect for their meaning and then used as a mere product or commercial activity. This trivializes a profound spiritual practice and often deprives Indigenous communities of control over their culture.
Q: What risks are associated with workshops manufacturing inauthentic drums?
A: Several risks can arise: the trivialization of spiritual traditions by reducing them to a fun workshop; ArtisanatAutochtone.com the commercial exploitation of a cultural heritage without compensation for indigenous communities; ArtisanatAutochtone.com the devaluation of indigenous artisans who practice respectfully and sincerely, in the face of popular “dilution” versions.
Q: How can one recognize a respectful drumming workshop as opposed to an appropriative one?
A: To identify respectful workshops: Make sure they are led by Indigenous people or collaborate directly with relevant communities. IndigenousCrafts.com Verify the origin of the materials and that their acquisition respects cultural practices and laws. IndigenousCrafts.com Consult with Indigenous communities: their opinion is often the best guide to judging the legitimacy of the workshops offered.